the best songs ever: the lost years - Printable Version +- Generational Theory Forum: The Fourth Turning Forum: A message board discussing generations and the Strauss Howe generational theory (http://generational-theory.com/forum) +-- Forum: Fourth Turning Forums (http://generational-theory.com/forum/forum-1.html) +--- Forum: Entertainment and Media (http://generational-theory.com/forum/forum-11.html) +--- Thread: the best songs ever: the lost years (/thread-200.html) |
RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - Ragnarök_62 - 06-18-2016 Eric Wrote:I think gabrielle touched on the difference between someone like me and you guys. For me, a "best song" has to have some level artistry that's similar in some ways to a classical music piece. A high level of artistry such that it could compare to the work of classical composers. And remember, those composers also wrote actual songs, not just symphonies. ... I actually agree with this. I like songs that confirm my sense of reality as it actually is. To wit, the state of relations between say Corporate America and folks like me. Balls To The Wall is a perfect example of this. No matter how you cut it, exploitation ain't pretty. Balls To The Wall hits on that reality hard and heavy, and confirms my attitude wrt Corporate America. Lyrics Wrote:Too many slaves in this world Quote:Something by boy bands or sexy girls to groove to that has a beat you can dance to, or some interesting lyrics, is different from that. Oh, but either the lyrics or the actual sound of rage are interesting. Quote:Not to mention deliberate decadence, like Rags is posting in this thread, which simply means poor quality music. To each his own; it's not a moral issue. It may be fun or funky for you guys, OK; but that's a difference. 1. You rang? 2. Well, again, it's the experience there. I was decadent in the 1980's years. I went full fledged Yuppie in regards to seeking $ (influenced by elders no doubt) and lot's of poker junkets. Quote:A great song by The Who may have some different instrumentation and singing that's not the same as a majestic and rocking Beethoven symphony finale. But otherwise they are the same; the best Who songs have magnificent form and structure, power and feeling that's like what I hear in Beethoven or Bach. Many great rock songs from the 2T can compare or surpass many classical works in those qualities. Critics of the time agreed. The Beatles and other musicians sometimes brought western and eastern classical influences into their music, and thereby raised it to a higher level of artistry. In my preferences, I hold music to the same standard of artistry, regardless of genre. 1. Newsflash, man. Not everyone uses music like Eric does. 2. Some 2T music certainly works because it's tied to some sort of nice memory. Quote:Not one preference for rock, another for classical, another for folk, etc. Those from the 3T, do not aspire to that kind of standard. It was perhaps just a question of what the musicians were interested in doing in those 2 different turnings. I'm sure the audiences were different. Quote:Also, the original purpose of music should be remembered. Music and the other arts are here to help facilitate mystical experience. Art is the handmaiden of spirituality. That's for prophet generations, man. RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - gabrielle - 06-18-2016 (06-18-2016, 03:54 PM)Eric the Green Wrote: I think gabrielle touched on the difference between someone like me and you guys. For me, a "best song" has to have some level artistry that's similar in some ways to a classical music piece. A high level of artistry such that it could compare to the work of classical composers. And remember, those composers also wrote actual songs, not just symphonies. Something by boy bands or sexy girls to groove to that has a beat you can dance to, or some interesting lyrics, is different from that. Not to mention deliberate decadence, like Rags is posting in this thread, which simply means poor quality music. To each his own; it's not a moral issue. It may be fun or funky for you guys, OK; but that's a difference. I thought that was the kind of music you liked. (Well, maybe not the sexy girls) Bieber, 1 Direction etc RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - Eric the Green - 06-18-2016 Comment on the video: A Who 80's anthem that never was. How did everybody miss this? 1982, from It's Hard "I've Known No War" I've known no war And if I ever do I won't know for sure Who'll be fighting whom For the soldiers lonely tomb Now opens as soon as the referee's gun starts to roar I'll know no war Galbraith took his pen To break down the men Of the German army defeated On the nineteenth day Of a spring day in May Albert Speer was deleted And as soon as the battle was over I was born in victorious clover And I've never been shot at or gassed Never tortured or stabbed And I'm sure - I'll never know war I know I'll never know war And if I ever do The glimpse will be short Fireball in the sky No front line battle cries Can be heard and the button is pushed By a soul that's been bought I'll know no war In and out of reach loft The medals are lost They belong to a lone broken sailor His provinces now Are the bars of the town His songs and his poems of failure For his grandchildren can't see the glory And his own kids are bored with the story But for him they'd have burned behind netting >From the brink they were grabbed And I'm sure I'll never know war I've known no war And if I ever do I won't know for sure Who'll be fighting whom For the soldiers lonely tomb Now opens as soon as the referee's gun starts to roar I'll know no war War - I've known no war I'll never know war And if I ever know it The glimpse will be short Fireball in the sky No front line battle cries Can be heard as the button is pushed by a soul that's been bought And the armies remaining will judge without people or courts And there's no point pretending that knowing will help us abort I'll know no war RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - Eric the Green - 06-18-2016 (06-18-2016, 09:04 PM)gabrielle Wrote: I thought that was the kind of music you liked. (Well, maybe not the sexy girls) Bieber, 1 Direction etc Ha ha. No, Bieber is not a boy band. He was a boy turned man who's a great artist. It's true though, as I have said; due to prejudice and mis-labelling, lots of mostly-older folks just can't hear his music. Although I see lots of comments on his videos to the effect of "I hated Bieber, but I'm surprised how much I like this song" or words to that effect. People here? No. But lots of people HAVE opened their ears to him over the years since he rose to fame as a teenage teen idol. 1D, yes, but they have put out some masterful songs; (including "the best song ever"; their best ever), obviously they had a LOT of help in the song-writing department, but now have taken to co-writing some of them. Born under the Uranus-Neptune conjunction heavily, Bieber and the 1D boys continue to show they have great potential, unlike most of the 80s and 90s boybands. THE kind of music I liked? Come on, you know better than to say that. RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - Eric the Green - 06-18-2016 (06-18-2016, 05:38 PM)Ragnarök_62 Wrote: I actually agree with this. I like songs that confirm my sense of reality as it actually is. To wit, the state of relations between say Corporate America and folks like me.....In the 3T, generally the actual sound of rage is annoying. For lyrics, you can read them. I am not knocking the lyrics, necessarily. Younger folks today are skilled with words, and enjoy them. I am more interested in going beyond the words to the music. Quote:1. You rang?I don't question or judge your experience. I only talk about music according to how I hear it. You can't reduce that hearing experience of music to you or me. Only in part is it a question of our personal experience. It's also the music itself. I would tend to say it's mostly the music itself, but I have no doubt that my personal needs and experiences color my listening too, and so it is with you and others. Quote:1. Newsflash, man. Not everyone uses music like Eric does.1. So what? Doesn't have anything to do with what I said. It's not what I use music for; it's what music is originally for. That's historic fact. 2. All music works in part because it's tied to some sort of memory for someone. In part, only. Quote:I'm sure the audiences were different. So audiences determine music? I thought composers did. Quote:That's for prophet generations, man. Nope. That's for all time. Joseph Campbell said it; he was a civic. RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - Ragnarök_62 - 06-18-2016 RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - gabrielle - 06-22-2016 Glancing over TaraMarie's picks for this era, I think perhaps her tastes are even more different from mine than Eric's--quite a bit more, actually! It seems to me she skipped over almost all of the good stuff in favor of late 90s/2000s pop. At least we are somewhat in agreement on early/mid 80s New Wave. But it's interesting to observe both the personal and generational differences in all of our music appreciation histories. Now, where was I...? 1984? (been a little busy lately) RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - gabrielle - 06-22-2016 Here's another from 1983 (that's when the album was released): RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - gabrielle - 06-22-2016 A classic from 1980 I missed: RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - gabrielle - 06-22-2016 1984: RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - gabrielle - 06-22-2016 Xmal Deutschland: "Mondlicht" 1984 I don't think this band was popular beyond the UK goth scene, but my first boyfriend got me into them (by that time, I think they were no longer a band). This song has a pretty rockin' beat. RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - gabrielle - 06-22-2016 Going back to somewhat more mainstream stuff for that year: RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - gabrielle - 06-22-2016 RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - gabrielle - 06-22-2016 Prince's Purple Rain album (and movie) came out this year, too. I would have picked Prince's "When Doves Cry" as my first choice from that album, but I believe Tara already mentioned that one. The title track was also very popular. Instead, I'll just mention a couple of Prince-penned songs from this year that have the distinction of being included on the Parents Music Resource Center's "Filthy Fifteen," a list of songs singled out for having a corrupting influence on youngsters. This moral furor over the supposedly wicked state of pop music eventually led to many of my favorite albums in the early 90s having parental warning stickers smacked on their covers. RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - gabrielle - 06-22-2016 This song was not on the Filthy 15, but it was banned by the BBC (even though it was a number 1 hit in the UK). I wouldn't really consider this one of the best songs of all time, but it was fun and I liked it back then (don't think my parents paid attention/cared). It was released in the UK in 1983 and the US in 1984. RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - gabrielle - 06-22-2016 Not amused. RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - gabrielle - 06-22-2016 (06-22-2016, 02:56 PM)taramarie Wrote:(06-22-2016, 12:55 PM)gabrielle Wrote: Glancing over TaraMarie's picks for this era, I think perhaps her tastes are even more different from mine than Eric's--quite a bit more, actually! It seems to me she skipped over almost all of the good stuff in favor of late 90s/2000s pop. At least we are somewhat in agreement on early/mid 80s New Wave. But it's interesting to observe both the personal and generational differences in all of our music appreciation histories. I don't expect everyone to like the same stuff I like. Not trying to throw shade or anything. A lot of the stuff I like is pretty mainstream, I think, but I do like a few things that might be weird to others. Music appreciation is a very personal thing. And I haven't actually listened to everything you've posted, it might take me a while to get through it all. RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - gabrielle - 06-22-2016 "People are people, so why should it be You and I should get along so awfully?" RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - gabrielle - 06-22-2016 RE: the best songs ever: the lost years - gabrielle - 06-22-2016 1985: Tears For Fears had a few lovely melodic hits in the mid 80s. This one opens with chiming piano notes, as if to ring in the new Turning! |