11-19-2022, 10:36 AM
(11-18-2022, 04:02 PM)Eric the Green Wrote:What's the value of the perspective of a senile old man? What's the value of the perspective of a corrupt politician? Biden isn't an anchor, he's a loose rudder that can't be fixed.(11-18-2022, 11:38 AM)David Horn Wrote:(11-17-2022, 02:59 PM)Eric the Green Wrote:(11-17-2022, 02:47 PM)David Horn Wrote:(11-17-2022, 02:34 PM)Eric the Green Wrote: Gavin Newsom (horoscope score 9-2 with Uranus rising like FDR) has the potential to get noticed beyond the Sierras, and has already campaigned against DeSantis. It may happen for real someday, although I don't think 2024 is the right time. DeSantis may have ambitions to be the Bolsonaro of the north, and he has captured the land of elders and cubans, but he does not have the power to take over and lead the Trump cult to victory, unless the Democrats do something stupid like dumping Biden for Harris (horoscope score 3-17) or any other failed 2020 candidate.
Most of the Dem leadership is over 80. That's simply not viable in an era where the emerging votes are from the young, not old farts who needed encouragement. Biden cannot run next time, or we'll stand better than even odds of having 8 years of Ron DeSanctimonious. Trump may create a replay of 1912, with Trump in the role of Teddy Roosevelt, but let's not try that on for size. The fit may be less than it appears.
It does not matter if Biden is over 80 or not. If he is the only viable messenger for these times, WHICH HE IS, then young people will vote for him, and have done so, regardless of whether they give him a positive approval rating. The polls are already showing this. Steady Joe Biden MUST run next time; he is the only high-scoring candidate we have, and his speeches recently show he's up to the job of running again. People can tell that my scores are correct. That will be my rebuttal to you again and again. Democrats cannot afford to nominate weak-sounding wonks like Pete Buttigieg or gabby incoherent gals like Amy Klobuchar or flaming tempers like Cory Booker or old crusader rabbit Elizabeth Warren. Biden (score 16-6) can beat DeTramp (score only 12-10) and the Chump (9-4) too.
http://philosopherswheel.com/presidentialelections.html
You mentioned 1912, which interestingly is just about the only anomaly in my system's record.
1912: Woodrow Wilson 11-9**, Theodore Roosevelt 11-16 J, William H. Taft 12-8 J/U, SN*
Taft had a slightly higher score than Wilson, though within the margin of error perhaps, and they both had a 4th year Saturn Return problem, but Taft had to run against both Wilson and former president Teddy Roosevelt, who actually had a low score (but Jupiter rising). Taft could not run against both Democrat Wilson and former Republican President Roosevelt and win as a Republican. Trump would have the same problem if he ran against Biden on a 3rd MAGA Party ticket and against DeSantis too. The odds would favor Biden on that one, and he also beats both of them scoring wise.
The young gave the geriatric Dems Some breathing room in 2022, but they, rightly, expect their turn at bat. At least the House caucus got the message. Moving to the youth now would be the right thing to do, even assuming that the White House is lost in 2024. It has to happen in the next cycle or be a rolling disaster in the following one. Win or lose in 2024, Biden will be a boat anchor in 2028, and that one we need to win outright.
Biden is our anchor, yes. We need his steady, if slow, leadership and perspective. I think he will run and win in 2024, since we have no-one else. If we did, I would be all in favor of him or her, and it would be the right thing to do. But we don't; just the luck of the draw. The general idea of supporting the rising generation does not apply to this specific office of the presidency in this specific time, given the personnel available. Many Boomers and Gen Xers who could have been great leaders turned away from politics in the USA, and this has limited our choices. Biden must run and win in 2024 or the saeculum is probably over and the US and the world fades away. Every 4T is a battle for the existence and the soul of the country. Joe gets it.