04-18-2021, 10:42 PM
(04-18-2021, 08:53 PM)Classic-Xer Wrote:(04-17-2021, 10:50 PM)pbrower2a Wrote: You ignore that no single tradition defines America. Many different traditions have validity in America, and if you do not recognize this, then you do not fully understand America.
There is plenty to despise about Donald Trump: his marital infidelity, his bigotry against many identifiable groups (including the handicapped), his sleazy history as a businessman, his suspect loyalty to America when Russia offered him more, his disdain for old decencies that make democracy work in America... were it not for his wealth, his business practices would have gotten him a prison term if he were not wise enough to allow his dreams to match what is allowed to people.
The more that I saw of the Trump administration and of the personality behind it the more I despised and dreaded it. You saw the stunt in which he had unidentifiable forces attacking protesters so that he could carry a Bible (that he neither heeds nor reads) in front of a church that he does not attend and show the most pitiable display of fake devotion that I have ever seen. I look at the personality cult and I see a dictator. I look at the vans in Portland and Seattle that had Trump banners and a US flag that took away protesters, which is how a secret police operates. I mocked that inchoate secret police as "Trump-Trump Macoutes" after the brutal secret of the Duvalier dictatorship in Haiti. I do not mock the Haitian people who deserve far better than that.
In the end we had a President who denied his manifest defeat and sought to set aside electoral results that he disliked -- with people willing to use force and violence. In the end, the Joint Chiefs of Staff made clear that Joe Biden had won the election and would become President on January 20, 2021. They needed say no more and needed explain nothing.
Joe Biden may not be one of those people who runs on a law-and-order stance, but that's not to say that he needs to.
Germany was a democracy before Hitler and the Nazi party were duly elected and sworn in and changed the rules/laws and took control over the country. A prime example of democratic socialism being used as means to gain control over a country. The most recent example of it being used for the same purposeis Venezuela. We ain't dumb or needy or naive or deaf and blind. So, of the 80 million who voted for Biden to save them from something, how many million are either dumb, impressionable or naive? How many are cream puffs who fear violence who don't have the courage to defend themselves or the heart to hurt anyone? How many are potheads who have little to no interest in working like Rags? How many have a mental illness of some sort that requires medicine for them to functions?
German democracy was shaky. Germany had no responsible conservative party. The significant German National People's Party was far-right, and irresponsible. From Wikipedia:
Quote: In his book, The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich, journalist and historian William Shirer wrote that the DNVP's status as a far-right party rather than a mainstream conservative party was one of the main reasons for the Weimar Republic's downfall. In Shirer's view, the DNVP's refusal to "take a responsible position either in the government or in the opposition" during most of Weimar's existence denied Weimar "that stability provided in many other countries by a truly conservative party."[209] Along similar lines, conservative British historian Sir John Wheeler-Bennett wrote about in his book The Nemesis of Power about the DNVP the following:Hitler quickly suppressed the Social Democrats, his main opposition in 1933. Hitler used the word "socialism", but he even called himself a democrat -- a "real" Democrat unlike one of those Jewish-influenced or even Jewish democrats like FDR (whom Hitler thought was Jewish).
Quote:Had the German Conservatives reconciled themselves to the Republic—bringing to it that wealth of experience and knowledge which they had accumulated in the past, and performing those invaluable services which are always fulfilled in the government of any country by an able constitutional Opposition, ready to take office should the occasion arise—they would have conferred a considerable benefit not only upon Germany—to whom they would have given that which she had so long lacked, a genuine Conservative Party—but also upon the cause of Conservatism throughout the world. They did not do this. Under the cloak of loyalty to the Monarchy, they either held aloof or sabotaged the efforts of successive Chancellors to give a stable government to the Republic. The truth is that after 1918 many German Nationalists were more influenced by feelings of disloyalty to the Republic than of loyalty to the Kaiser, and it was this motive which led them to make their fatal contribution to bringing Hitler to power. The sequel is to be found in the long list of noble names among those executed after the Putsch of July 20, 1944, when many expiated upon the scaffold the sins which they or their fathers had committed a generation earlier.[210]
There was no alternative, and no way in which to say "no". That is little different from how things are done in North Korea today.
Just because the ballot reads "Reichstag for Freedom and Peace" foes not mean that Germany was in any way free, and that peace and war were strictly the choice of the Fuehrer. The Nazi Party claimed to be Socialist, which like much else about the Party, its leadership, and its agenda were enormous lies. German workers would soon be serfs to their employers, unable to quit their jobs without the consent of their employers. Such was the arrangement between feudal lords and their peasants in the late middle ages. Nazi Germany was socialist only in nationalizing property of Jews -- basically the "socialism of thieves".
Don't ask me to defend Hugo Chavez or his successor Nicolas Maduro. Chavez slowly degraded democracy in Venezuela and Maduro has kept the screws tight.
...81 million Americans voted for Joe Biden in a way that got him 306 electoral votes, which is how he became President. Many of those voted for Hillary Clinton in 2016, but you didn't see them challenging the election even though she lost the Electoral College despite getting a plurality of the vote. Nobody can credibly accuse Donald Trump of winning through fraud, either his or that of someone else, so we were stuck with him. Claims that Trump got cheated in 2020 are shakier than those in which might have been used against the Trump election of 2016 (there were allegations of Trump getting help from his friends in Russia, but that can't quite be proven -- and it is too late to do anything about that.
You can fault people for voting for someone other than Donald Trump for reasons that you consider specious. This said, President Trump did much to degrade American democracy, and enough people saw the danger of that in 2020. His attempted self-coup on January 6 demonstrates his contempt for Constitutional norms, in that he is much more like Hugo Chavez than you might want to believe, except that Chavez degraded Venezuelan democracy more slowly and effectively
Down with Donald Trump and Nicolas Maduro alike!
The ideal subject of totalitarian rule is not the convinced Nazi or the dedicated Communist but instead the people for whom the distinction between fact and fiction, true and false, no longer exists -- Hannah Arendt.