*** 10-Nov-16 World View -- Donald Trump: The honeymoon calm before the storm
This morning's key headlines from
GenerationalDynamics.com
- Donald Trump victory signals a major increase in nationalism
- Brexit referendum and US election illustrate dangers of predicting elections
- The honeymoon calm before the storm
- Is this the Apocalypse?
****
**** Donald Trump victory signals a major increase in nationalism
****
Supporters and opponents of Donald Trump outside Trump Tower in Manhattan on Wednesday (Boston Globe)
Two weeks ago, I wrote
Clinton e-mail media storm shows sudden change in public mood
after FBI Director
James B. Comey made a Friday afternoon announcement that he might
re-open the Clinton e-mail case. Friday afternoon announcements,
including many previous announcements about Benghazi and Clinton
e-mail dumps, are almost always immediately forgotten, but this one
created a media storm in the mainstream media, indicating a sudden
change in public mood.
As I wrote at the time, from the point of view of Generational
Dynamics, the media storm was much more important than whether Clinton
was guilty or innocent, because it indicated that the public mood was
changing. And that media storm was a harbinger of the Trump victory
which was a surprise to almost every media source and almost every
polling organization.
Now Donald Trump has to govern. He's very similar to Barack Obama in
that neither has the vaguest clue what's going on in the world. And
after eight years in office, Obama seems to know as little today about
what's going on in the world as he did eight years ago.
It remains to be seen whether Donald Trump will be any better at
learning what's going on in the world than Barack Obama. Boomers are
generally less arrogant and more willing to listen to reason than
Gen-Xers, so there's hope.
One thing that his staff might do is develop some expertise in
generational theory. Generational Dynamics is a non-ideological
methodology that does analyses using MIT's System Dynamics applied to
changes in generations. Since 2003, the
GenerationalDynamics.com web site contains thousands of articles
with hundreds of predictions, all of which have turned out to be
right. There is no web site, analyst, politician or journalist with a
success record in correct analyses and forecasts that comes even
close to the Generational Dynamics success.
If the staff of Donald Trump, or any other politician in the country
or the world, wants to base policy on what's actually going on in the
world, rather than on fatuous left-wing or right-wing ideologies that
are almost always wrong, then they should develop an understanding of
generational theory, and read the daily World View articles.
Related Articles
****
**** Brexit referendum and US election illustrate dangers of predicting elections
****
As I've been writing for years, starting long before the current
election, this is a generational Crisis era, and as in other Crisis
eras, nationalism, racism and xenophobia have been increasing in
countries around the world.
This trend illustrates why pollsters have been so wrong in both the
Brexit referendum and the US elections. Pollsters were using models
that date back to the 1990s, a generational Unraveling era when the
Silent generation was still in charge, and knew the enormous dangers
of nationalism, racism and xenophobia from having survived World War
II. Polling organizations using 1990s models simply did not see the
change in attitudes caused by the disappearance of the generations of
survivors of World War II.
During the campaign, I was asked several times whether Generational
Dynamics could predict the result of the election. The easy answer is
that Chaos Theory proves that election results cannot be predicted,
and any polling organization would agree.
For those who would like some additional technical details about this,
I use a fairly simple test to determine whether or not something can
be predicted.
When I want to decide whether something can or cannot be predicted, I
use what I call "the butterfly test." You may have heard about the
finding from Chaos Theory that a butterfly flapping its wings in China
could start a chain reaction that might (or might not) cause a
hurricane in North America. That's one reason why it's mathematically
impossible to accurately predict the weather more than about two weeks
in advance. No matter how advanced weather science becomes,
whether forecasting will never be any better than it is now.
So I build on that concept. A butterfly flapping its wings in China
could cause a hurricane in North America, and that could cause people
to stay home, changing the outcome of an election. Since something as
tiny as a butterfly flapping its wings could change the outcome of an
election, there's no hope of predicting the outcome of an election.
Or if you use polls to predict the results of an election, you likely
have no better than a 50-50 or 55-45 chance of getting it right.
What generational theory does do is predict broad trends involving
entire populations or entire generations. These trends can't be
affected by a butterfly flapping its wings because there are too many
people involved. People have free will, so you can't predict the
actions of an individual or a small group of people, but you can
predict many things about an entire population or an entire
generation.
****
**** The honeymoon calm before the storm
****
Almost everyone I know hated this presidential campaign, as the two
candidates at times seemed to be in a race to be more sickening and
disgusting than the other. How low could the country go?
Pollster Frank Luntz, appearing on 60 Minutes last Sunday, has been
conducting political focus groups for years, and he traces the growth
in political vitriol as starting in the 2000 presidential election,
when Al Gore won the popular vote, but George W. Bush became president
after six weeks and a Supreme Court decision. According to Luntz:
> [indent]
<QUOTE>"And in that six weeks, we came from being Democrats
> and Republicans to being outraged, to believing that the other
> side is trying to steal the election. And when the election was
> over, there was no coming together. There was no honeymoon. And
> from that point on, the goal has been to delegitimize. Not to
> respect and at least to listen to, but to delegitimize the
> opposition. And now today in 2016, hours from now, it will be tens
> of millions of people who will believe that the loser should have
> won, that the election was rigged, and that the winner is
> illegitimate. ...
>
> I feel like I’m a child of a divorce. These two candidates, the
> way they fight, the way they yell at each other, the way they make
> it personal, it’s like having your parents get divorced, and you
> don’t want to live with either of them. And the judge sits there
> and says, “Pick one or the other.” And you say, “How about the
> jury? Can I-- can I go there?” It’s awful."<END QUOTE>[/indent]
Luntz suggested that the "social media" is at fault. "There were
people in that focus group who used language that if my mom was still
alive and I said it, she would literally cut me out of the
will. There’s no self-censoring. So we now say exactly what we
feel. And, goddamn it, you’re gonna listen to me. And that’s really
what it is right now. You’re gonna listen to me. I’m not gonna learn
from you. You’re gonna listen to me."
Many people are hoping that the vitriolic attacks will end, now that
the election is over, and that things can return to "normal." And
when they say "normal," they mean the 1990s -- a generational
Unraveling era. That's not going to happen.
The generational Crisis era ("Fourth Turning") officially began in
2003, 58 years after the end of World War II, as the last of the
Silent generation retired. The vitriolic attacks on George Bush had
begun a couple of years earlier, as Luntz described, but they've only
become worse since then, and they've gone in both directions between
Republicans and Democrats.
I titled this article "the honeymoon calm before the storm" as kind of
a joke. New presidents are supposed to have a "honeymoon" that lasts
100 days or so into his new administration, but that was before the
rise of Generation-X. Trump will be lucky if his "honeymoon" lasts
the rest of this month.
This kind of chaotic storm always happens during a generational Crisis
era. In the 1930s, President Franklin Roosevelt was deeply hated for
many of his decisions. One of the worst was his decision to try to
"pack" the Supreme Court by expanding it 15 judges, in order to get
the court to stop declaring his favorite new laws unconstitutional.
And you can imagine how vitriolic the attacks must have become when
Roosevelt became the first US president to run for a third term.
The previous generational Crisis era saw the election in 1860 of
Abraham Lincoln as president. This infuriated the Southern states,
and led to the Civil War.
Many people are describing what's happening today as unique in
American history. That's far from true. What's happening today
happens in every country in every generational Crisis era.
CBS 60 Minutes and
History.com
Related Articles (58-year hypothesis)
****
**** Is this the Apocalypse?
****
I heard several journalists on the BBC and RFI on Wednesday talk about
the end of the world, the Apocalypse. There were several reasons why
the world was going to end. One was because Trump was going to end
climate change talks, and we're all going to freeze to death ... I
mean, burn to death. And the other was because Trump was going to
start a nuclear war, and start dropping nuclear bombs on everyone.
Nobody mentioned the Apocalypse caused by an attack by China.
This talk of Apocalypse is silly, but it's also not far from the
truth. President Roosevelt's term led to World War II, and President
Lincoln's term led to the Civil War. That's what happens during a
generational Crisis era, no matter who's president.
As I've been writing for years, the world is headed for a new world
war, the Clash of Civilizations world war. The allies of the West
will include Japan, India, Russia and Iran. The enemies will be
China, Pakistan, and the Sunni Muslim countries. This will be the
greatest war in history. By the time it's over, every nuclear weapon
in the world will have been used on someone. I estimate that the
total deaths from nuclear war, ground war, famine and disease to be
around 3-4 billion people, leaving around 4 billion people to rebuild
the world.
And here's another little bit of irony. Assuming that this war begins
during Donald Trump's term in office, and assuming that the United
States survives the war, then Trump will become a national hero, with
the stature of Roosevelt and Lincoln.
Related Articles
KEYS: Generational Dynamics, Donald Trump, James Comey,
Brexit, Chaos Theory, Butterfly test,
Frank Luntz, 60 Minutes, Fourth Turning,
Franklin Roosevelt, Abraham Lincoln
Permanent web link to this article
Receive daily World View columns by e-mail
Contribute to Generational Dynamics via PayPal
John J. Xenakis
100 Memorial Drive Apt 8-13A
Cambridge, MA 02142
Phone: 617-864-0010
E-mail: john@GenerationalDynamics.com
Web site:
http://www.GenerationalDynamics.com
Forum:
http://www.gdxforum.com/forum
Subscribe to World View:
http://generationaldynamics.com/subscribe